platoon vs full metal jacket

And after both of those films told us Vietnam was incomprehensible... Kubrick decodes it for us. I don't know but I've been told, watching Full Metal Jacket never gets old. Full Metal Jacket is a great film, but its first half was the main highlight. Share this page: Recent Activity. Marvel. > Coming Home In A Body Bag 2 > Platoon. The most noticeable thing is that even after the bullet reaches the target, it is still jacketed. Both are outstanding, but Full Metal Jacket is more entertaining in a sense that it has more replay value, imo. The official Facebook Page for Full Metal Jacket. Platoon is overdramatic, lacks focus, and really doesn't have any lasting impact. FMJ: great dialogue, tons of subliminal satire on the war, good cinematography. It is iconic and D'onofrio's portrayal of Private Pyle is mezmerizing. Full metal jackets cost less for practice. Full Metal Jacket study guide contains a biography of Stanley Kubrick, literature essays, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full summary and analysis. This is a difficult choice with a slight preference to the gripping Full Metal Jacket. It's difficult to compare the two, even though both deal with "the horror" of Vietnam .."Full Metal Jacket" is more of a 2 movies in one kind of film, while "Platoon" is a balls out bloody affair set in the jungle, while FMJ focuses on mental health in basic training and the shocking reality of violence of the war ...Platoon manages to give the viewer a look inside the inner workings of soldiers dealing with the viciousness in themselves and their fellow soldiers. Hartman was gonna die by Pvt. 855 talking about this. The second half supposedly was about the Battle for Hue City in the Tet Offensive of 1968 which I fought in and was wounded. Platoon keeps me interested the whole way, yet it manages to convey a message without lacking enjoyment. Neither of those two movies mentioned in the original question are anywhere remotely close to what I saw there as a 1LT Artillery Forward Observer there in 1968–69. I knew Sgt. The first half of Full Metal Jacket beats Platoon. 3. The first half is interesting, but after that it feels like it just drags on and lacks pace. socalgator voted for Full Metal Jacket (1987) Rohan163 voted for Platoon (1986) ainarvau voted for Full Metal Jacket (1987) jeremysakamaki voted for Full Metal Jacket (1987) Poll FAQ. Neben Filmen wie „2001: Odyssee im Weltraum“, „Uhrwerk Orange“ oder „Shining“, dürfte „Full Metal Jacket“ sicherlich der bekannteste sein. Platoon wins! | Born to Kill Star Wars. Platoon all day Full Metal Jacket always felt off too me, almost like a caricature FMJ is the greatest Vietnam film. Some movies are more quotable than others, and Stanley Kubrick’s classic “Full Metal Jacket” certainly fits that bill. Platoon was very realistic regarding the feelings and firefights that ensued in a combat platoon which I was in. It maybe doesnt present idea to the degree of FMJ … Full metal jacket is laced with humour but overall is about the way war make men out of boys. General Boards. And Platoon is definitely the more complete film. Lol..Platoon is the better and more complete film. But after some growing up and many repeat viewings of both, my still developing concept of the Vietnam Conflict has compelled me to choose Full Metal. With Full Metal Jacket, the battle scenes feel more like that of a World War II movie than a Vietnam War movie. Full Metal Jacket is overrated by most..simply because Stanley Kubrick directed it. Is it serious, a comedy, a dark comedy or just ridiculous? Tough tie between FMJ vs Platoon. Platoon is great all the way through. Platoon (1986) IMDb Polls Follow @IMDb on Twitter. Full Metal Jacket (1987) Vote! A poll by Chihir0. Even though the second half isn't as good as the first, it is still very entertaining and well made. Hartman is basically a quote goldmine. Platoon is excellent. Replacement soldiers (i.e. Sergeants ran the platoons in many cases. Platoon Full Metal Jacket; Domestic Release Date: Dec 19, 1986: Jun 26, 1987: Production Budget: $6,000,000: $30,000,000: Opening Weekend Theaters: 215: Maximum Theaters: 1,560: 974: Theatrical Engagements: 24,983: 5,478: Domestic Opening Weekend : $2,217,307: Domestic Box Office: $137,963,328: $45,015,999: Inflation Adjusted Domestic Box Office: $323,865,082: $105,459,474 Great separation between the different acts, and fantastic character development. Now Playing and Upcoming Films. They tell the story of a group of marine grunts undergoing basic training on Paris Island, and the experience comes down to a confrontation between the gunnery sergeant and a tubby misfit (Vince D'Onofrio) who is nicknamed Gomer Pyle. True dat. or Create A New Account ►. ... who Joker meets upon arriving in Phu Bai and joining up with the platoon. Poll: Face-Off: Full Metal Jacket vs. Platoon. FMJ for its superior dark comedy and pacing, Platoon is more whiny by comparison. Find similar movies with our Report Builder. If you want a good Vietnam film from Oliver Stone, Born on the Fourth of July is the way to go. R. Lee Ermey and Stanley Kubrick own. Platoon is slightly better than Full Metal Jacket. Sign In Now ► HH was the weakest of the 3 you originally listed. And this post right here is my argument against Full Metal Jacket. Ronald Lee Ermey (March 24, 1944 – April 15, 2018) was an American actor, and Marine drill instructor. Full Metal Jacket is a classic. So not one really is the best. Trivia and Games. Full Metal Jacket all the way. Platoon is a good movie and I'm glad I saw it but in a battle against Full Metal Jacket it will lose every time. Nu is de film ook beschikbaar in 4K. In jedem Fall zählt er aber zu den bedeutendsten und bedrückendsten Anti-Kriegsfilmen, ich würde ihn in einem Atemzug mit „Platoon… The opening passages of "Full Metal Jacket" promise much more than the film finally is able to deliver. Note: A theatrical engagement is defined as the movie playing in a single theater for one week. 1. I just don't understand how Full Metal Jacket has been so highly favoured here. Lol..Platoon is the better and more complete film. I really liked Platoon and didn't enjoy Full Metal Jacket. 7 years, 7 months ago. I Need to Know. And Platoon is definitely the more complete film. No contest. Platoon's absolutely terrific, but it's a far cry away from Full Metal Jacket. Full Metal Jacket means a bullet that is covered entirely by a jacket. Full Metal Jacket is a 1987 war film directed, co-written, and produced by Stanley Kubrick and starring Matthew Modine, R. Lee Ermey, Vincent D'Onofrio and Adam Baldwin. Protozoid--you are very intelligent. Kubrick is a mastermind. Paraphrasing meanbobs , "I don't know but I've been told, watching Full Metal Jacket never gets old." Cherries) were treated like dirt. IMDB2 Information. Taken as just a tutorial on the Vietnam experience, “Platoon” teaches a number of things to an audience not well-read on the subject. FMJ is so damn messy and inconsistent. Which one of these 80s highest rated movies about Vietnam War you like most? The screenplay by Kubrick, Michael Herr, and Gustav Hasford was based on Hasford's 1979 novel The Short-Timers. Baker's Dozen. Neither is a masterpiece, but Platoon is WAY more overrated. Nu is de film ook beschikbaar in 4K. Full Metal Jacket and Platoon are clearly two of the biggest movies ever made about the Vietnam War; therefore, they will always be compared and contrasted to each other. But full metal jacket stood out the most, it shows bootcamp to Vietnam and gomer pyle scene shows how someone with a weak mind can be pushed to the edge. While Platton is a harsh portrayal of a solider’s experience, FMJ is a satire on the war. 33, Feb. 1988, pp. It was bloody house to house fighting which they didn't depict. The official Facebook Page for Full Metal Jacket. But the movie was not realistic in its' aspect of that battle as it was made as so weird and some kind of surrealistic footage of the battle. Platoon Vs. Full Metal Jacket. There is no difference when shooting practice and self-defense. Oops! No contest. I respect FMJ, and the first half is both entertaining and deplorable at the same time, which works very much to it's advantage. Full Metal Jacket wins. Full metal Jacket planted itself deeply in my film lexicon and I have enjoyed it several time since my first viewing when it came out. Full Metal Jacket bleek de een-na-laatste film van Kubrick en één van zijn beste. Platoon was based on Oliver Stone’s own experience so he used simple war movie In a way, Full Metal Jacket is the wholly grim counterpart of 2001. General Discussion. I prefer Full Metal Jacket, but Platoon ain't far behind. Also, with Platoon I really have the feeling like I am in Vietnam. Full Metal Jacket and Platoon are clearly two of the biggest movies ever made about the Vietnam War; therefore, they will always be compared and contrasted to each other. Every soldier … 28-30 copyright Jump Cut: A Review of Contemporary Media, 1988, 2006 . The first half of Full Metal Jacket is brilliant, but the second half is not that great. Full Metal Jacket has philosophy all over it esb1118 FMJ may be deeper but I think Platton does an incredible job of Showing war. Platoon is completely forgettable, and FMJ is a freakin' classic. Full Metal Jacket Back to Vietnam. DC. that comparisons are, well, odious. After seeing both for the first time decades ago, I favored P over FMJ. The best parts of the movie were in boot camp. In my opinion, Platoon is the better movie. So, for example, a film that plays in 3,000 theaters in its first week and 2,000 theaters in its second week will have had 5,000 theatrical engagements. And I totally agree with "dystopia". It doesn't help that the script is all over the place and everything only loosely connects! Full Metal Jacket > Deer Hunter > Apocalypse Now > Hamburger Hill > Band of Brothers > Casualties of War > Boys in Company C (featuring R Lee Emry as a shouty drill instructor!) For self-defense, you can't beat a Hallow Point. Platoon for me. Some people ask me what is the best Vietnam war movie and I say there are parts of FMJ, Platoon, The Deer Hunter, Apocalypse Now, and Hamburger Hill that depict all aspects of that War. A few years ago, we compiled its list of the 32 best military movie quotes of all time, but once we got to “Full Metal Jacket,” we realized it was hard to pick just one, since Gunnery Sgt. Popular Movie Franchises. Because they cannot admit defeat, they send in guy after guy and... well, just watch the film. 2. from Jump Cut, no. Classic match up, was pleased to see this. Met een productiebudget van zo'n 30 miljoen dollar wist de oorlogsfilms zo'n 46 miljoen dollar op te halen in de States en wereldwijd staat de teller op ongeveer 130 miljoen dollar. You forgot the text part of your comment. In jedem Fall zählt er aber zu den bedeutendsten und bedrückendsten Anti-Kriegsfilmen, ich würde ihn in einem Atemzug mit „Platoon… 893 talking about this. by Shai D. in Movies. 1.apocalypse now 2.fmj 3.platoon Full Metal Jacket is slightly better in my opinion. Apocalypse Now beats the crap outta both these films. The last 20 minutes of FMJ alone make this no contest. Platoon was based on Oliver Stone’s own experience so he used simple war movie techniques to give a realistic sense of what jungle warfare was like. Platoon is good but it's Full Metal Jacket easily for me, I think Platoon is a way better movie but I do like FMJ a lot.

Bootscharter Keser Seepferdchen 37, Hawaiian Tropic Sport 15, Leni Klum Geburtstag, Heck Auf Englisch, Kurzform Von Renate 4 Buchstaben,